Budget Analysis And Research Centre Trust

Recent Studies

Understanding the role and related capacities of Sathin for effective implementation of State women policy and child/women related LSDGs (2024)

BARC Trust conducted a study with support of UNICEF on current roles of Sathins and the challenge faced by them and how can they best contribute in achieving the women and child related SDGs. The primary purpose of the study was to understand the roles that Sathins are performing in the current context including some of their major accomplishments, identify the challenges faced by Sathins and recommend actions that can support the two departments in strengthening the role of Sathins especially vis-à-vis the State Women’s Policy and localization of women and child related SDGs.


The study adopted a mixed methods approach using both quantitative and qualitative information collected through both primary and secondary sources of data. Secondary data was collected through literature review covering available articles, reports, monographs as well as information collected from the two departments. For primary data a randomized sampling approach was adopted for identifying an ideal mix of Sathins, Sathin Supervisors, Sarpanch, Village Development Officers, Block Development Officers, Deputy/ Additional Director of Women Empowerment and Chief Executive Officers of Zilla Parishads. The information was collected using both Key Informant Interviews (KIIs) and Focused Group Discussions (FGDs). Report of the study was published jointly by UNICE and DWCD, GoR, acknowledging BARC’s contributions.

 

Challenges faced by Sathins: Sathins asserted that their roles and responsibilities are not clearly specified, which is further affected by lack of inter-departmental coordination. Trainings of Sathins are too few and far between. Sathins work at the gram panchayat level catering on an average, to a population of nearly 5000 individuals of which nearly half would be women. When compared with the other frontline functionaries operating within the gram panchayat jurisdiction the honorarium received by Sathins, despite an increase over time, continues to be very low. Sathins do not have a dedicated office space to work or to keep their records. Sathins also stated that, opposition from elderly and influential people, and being seen as against the established socio-cultural norms and traditions all act as hindrances. However, when faced with these challenges they often do not get the desired support from the system.

 

The study found that the sathins can play the important roles as gender and child rights catalyst and made following key recommendations:

  • Sathins roles in health, nutrition and formation of SGHs should be deprioritised / dropped as there are other frontline workers / programmes working in those areas.
  • Sathins can form village level groups of adolescent boys and girls.
  • The jajam meetings should be linked with the quarterly Mahila Sabha meetings
  • Sathins role in spreading awareness and linking women and girls with government schemes and services such as One Stop Crisis Centre and Mahila Salah Evam Suraksha Kendras should not only continue but also be strengthened by establishing a formal referral mechanism wherein it becomes easy to ascertain and quantify her contribution in referring and linking women and girls with government schemes and support services.
  • A niche role for Sathins can also be explored in creating awareness on women’s and girls’ land/ property rights and asset ownership, linkages with economic empowerment schemes of the government, etc.
  • Sathins can also play a key role in strengthening the operationalization of localization of SDGs approach especially focusing on improving women’s participation in Mahila Sabha, Gram Sabha and GPDP process, conducting an annual ‘safety audit’ in gram panchayat and linking the findings with the GPDP process etc.
Functionality of Village Water and Sanitation Committees (VWSCs) for achieving goals under Jal Jeevan Mission in Rajasthan (2023)

BARC Trust, with support of UNICEF Rajasthan, gathered field insights, to understand the views and perceptions of the community itself and particularly of the members of the Village Water and Sanitation Committees (VWSCs) formed under the Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM) on the implementation of the JJM in general and the role and functionating of VWSCs in particular. The field insight exercise was conducted with following objectives:

Methodology: Both quantitative and quantitative data were collected by BARC trust team. The quantitative data has been collected from the members of VWSC from each selected village, using scheduled questionnaire on Google Forms. Generally, 4–8 members of the VWSC were present during the interview and provided a collective answer to each question of the questionnaire. 

 

And for qualitative data, interviews of the residents of the village, ward panch and sarpanch as well as Implementation Support Agency (ISA) coordinators were conducted and FGDs were also conducted with the men and women in the some of the selected villages. 

Sample: All the certified as well as the reported villages having achieved 100% FHTC were taken from the JJM dashboard from the Jaipur, Karauli and Pratapgarh districts of the state. Beside 10 more villages where the JJM work is going on but have not achieved 100% FHTC were also included in the study. In total 57 villages from three districts were included in the Field Insight exercise.

Major Findings: The study found that though the VWSCs or Pani Samitis have been formed in all the villages included in the study, in many cases the committee members whom we interacted were not aware of the total members, number of women members, number of SC/ST members or members from the farthest dhani of the villages. Only in two (2) villages, VWSC members had received some training, in rest of villages no training was provided to the members.

Most of the VWSC members were not aware of the main components of JJM. Generally, the Village Action Plan was not made or approved in the Gram Sabha neither the VWSC members played any roles in developing VAPs. Only in 40% of the villages the VWSC members said that Water Supply System had reached all the dhanis of the villages, in about one-third of the villages (32%) the Water Supply System had not reached all the dhanis and in rest of the villages members did not know about it.

In some villages the complaints were made about water supply not being done everyday and in some cases its being done not for complete one hour. In some other villages the farther dhanis or the dhanis on upper part of the villages water could not reach in all families of the dhanis. Another major complaint was that the resourceful persons are using electric motors to collect more water in their houses when the water is being supplied and this results in less or no water being supplied to the other households, especially the farther ones and on upper levels.

Though the JJM guideline emphasizes on community participation and greater role of the VWSC in its planning and implementation, the implementation on the ground seems to be done by the PHED and contractors, taking the elected panchayat representatives help only in collecting the HH contributions. Even the panchayat does not seem to have played major roles, except where the sarpanch was active and took personal interest in implementation of JJM.

Strengthening Planning and Budgeting Interventions to Address Sexual and Gender Based Violence: Scoping Studies in Delhi, Madhya Pradesh, Punjab and Rajasthan (2022)

BARC Trust collaborated and contributed to this important scoping study led by Centre for Budget and Governance Accountability (CBGA), New Delhi and supported by UN Women on planning and budgeting interventions to address sexual and gender-based violence (SGBV) in 4 states of the country, including Rajasthan. BARC Trust collaborated with CBGA to provide support in the study in Rajasthan. The report of study can be accessed here on the UN Women website.